Patient Stories

A Heart for Diving

phil scuba diving after heart valve replacement impact everyday

Main Article Content

Phil’s Aortic Valve Replacement

Phil had one question during his heart surgery consultation: Would he be able to scuba dive afterward? His cardiovascular surgeon, Patrick M. McCarthy, MD, could only laugh.

Three years prior, Phil had to give up scuba diving because of an obstruction that would ultimately require a valve replacement and aneurysm repair. An unprecedented lack of energy and stamina meant he no longer felt safe diving. When it came time to get treatment, he chose to travel from Florida to Chicago to see Dr. McCarthy and Robert Silverberg, MD. A combination of personal reasons and Dr. McCarthy’s track record gave Northwestern Memorial Hospital the edge over other care centers across the country. It was a decision the 60-year-old emergency room doctor would not regret.

“They treated me so well, I think they did everything perfectly,” Phil remembered. “I’m a physician, I know the way it should be and Northwestern Memorial Hospital really has it together, they do it right every step of the way.”

At his consultation in January – the same at which he asked about scuba diving – Phil showed his understanding of what was going on, the potential risk and what would come next. He knew what his condition would require and the group scheduled surgery for March.

Phil was born with bicuspid aortic valve, which is the most common congenital heart defect. He would require a Bentall procedure – the aforementioned valve replacement and aneurysm repair. While a rare procedure for some hospitals, Dr. McCarthy and the Northwestern Medicine team perform valve replacements almost once a week. Three days after the procedure, Phil went home, two weeks later he was back in Florida and five months after his heart surgery, he was back in the water. Just in time for lobster season.

“Scuba diving has been a huge part of my life since I was 10 years old,” Phil said. “I grew up in Indiana, but I’ve lived in Florida, I’ve lived in the Caribbean and the whole time my favorite thing to do in life was scuba diving. It’s beautiful.”

“I’m telling you, these people saved my life,” Phil continued. “They’ve made it to where I’m enjoying every day again.”

The Northwestern Medicine team was able to do so in large part because of the Martha and Richard Melman Family Bicuspid Aortic Valve Program. The first of its kind, the program combines clinical care with research, pairing cardiologists and cardiac surgeons with researchers to ensure the most appropriate treatment. The research part of the program publishes papers on topics ranging from surgical outcomes and 4D MRI technology to patient care and the science behind specific mechanisms, including understanding why some patients, like Phil, develop aneurysms and others do not.

Interested in hearing more from Northwestern Medicine? Sign up for the Healthy Tips E‑Newsletter for everything from health and wellness ideas to patient breakthroughs to academic and medical advancements.